Welcome to my Valentine craftiness. How about an arrow holder made from an old wooden spool? I still used only what I have on hand. There’s something to be said about craft supply hoarding.
I used some ribbon and trim, a foam punched heart, and an old wood spool that I painted white.
First I glued my ribbon and trim onto the spool.
Then I glued the foam punched heart on.
I used the ribbon woven arrows that I made here. I clipped the ends off and wound a little trim around the skewers, dabbing glue on the ends. They fit right in the spool with no problem.
Cuteness in under an hour.